Log In

Don't have an account? Sign up now

Forgot Password?

Sign Up

Password will be generated and sent to your email address.

David Longwell on Player Development in the US and Scotland

David Longwell says the return of Under-20s football could help build a better pathway to the top for young players in Scotland.

National team boss Steve Clarke has already warned that the country needs to change its approach to developing young talent. And a Scottish FA report earlier this year said that clubs are failing to bring through enough young players, adding that Scottish football is “significantly underachieving its potential” in youth development compared to other countries of a similar size.

Longwell has worked as an academy director in Scotland and England, as well as in North America’s MLS with Orlando City and New York Red Bulls. As academy manager at St Mirren, he helped bring through John McGinn, Kenny McLean, and Lewis Morgan – all now key members of Clarke’s Scotland squad. Longwell said:

“When Mark Wotte was in charge at the SFA he introduced the Under-20s league, and in that league, you could play three over-age players. This turned out to be a very good idea. Every club had to play on a Monday or Tuesday evening, and it had to be in a stadium. It was beneficial in bringing young players through.

“I genuinely thought what was in place then worked. It allowed clubs to play young players like we did to accelerate their development but when required, it also allowed first-team players to gain minutes. It was up to each club how they used the Under-20s league but as we used it as a vehicle for development, there were so many young players who progressed to our first team.

“I sat in a meeting and they talked about going back to the reserve league — I thought that was crazy because the Under-20s league was working. However, at that time it was being driven by people who weren’t on the ground. I can only judge it on myself and the club I was at, but we used that league to play young players.

David Longwell conducting an analysis session
Image: Burnley FC

“We were giving young players the opportunity to play in a stadium and play against maybe Rangers, Celtic, and other teams who might have brought in some older players, but the young players were being stretched against good professionals. I remember our young players playing against Scott Allan who was at Celtic at this time and the experience our players got was invaluable.

“It’s not about anyone winning leagues or cups, that’s a bonus — what you must do is accelerate the players and challenge them quicker. It’s important, of course, that players are competitive and develop a winning mentality — but not at the cost of their long-term progression to playing first-team football. No one will remember who won the youth league in 2020 but if there are five players from that group playing in your first team now, then that is true success.

“If we had young players at St Mirren, they played in that Under-20s league and it was a challenge for them. If they were getting a little bit older then you put them out on loan. I think that’s the way it should be still. Young players need to get to first-team football as soon as possible. If they are not going to get it with their own team, then there should be somewhere else for them to get that experience.

“The way we used it, it worked. I didn’t see a reason to change it. We used it to our advantage and all those players I mentioned — McGinn, McLean, and Morgan — they were part of that to a degree, and they got to play in games that really helped their development.

“On top of these players, there was then Kyle McCallister, Kyle Magennis, Sean Kelly, Jason Naismith, and more who all came through the St Mirren Academy where the Under-20s system aided their development. The U20s system could be used for accelerating young players but was also beneficial for players who needed more time to develop.”

Longwell, who was most recently academy director at Burnley, spent three years in the MLS and saw first-hand how US clubs could plug the gap between Under-18 football and the first team. In many ways, there were similarities to the Under-20 system in Scotland.

David Longwell leading a training session
Image: Burnley FC

He added: “In the US, you’ve got Under-18s then you’ve got your MLS Next Pro level — but again, it’s an area you can use to give players time. In Scotland, it has gotten harder. You’re having to make decisions so early on players.

“Not every kid is a late developer. Some are just not going to be good enough, but I do think there are some kids who need that extra time. At Under-21s groups in England, what I was trying to do was use them for the best reasons — so that the best young talent was getting pushed but also for players who needed a bit more time to develop. And it was the same in the US. One of the reasons to have MLS Next Pro is to have a team right underneath the first team. They can play first-team players, but it also gives you the opportunity to play your best young talent.

“The concern I have is: have they actually been training enough and playing enough meaningful games? Genuinely, I think the Tuesday nights with the Under-20s worked. We were playing 16- and 17-year-olds in a good level of game in a stadium with people watching, and that is massive for young players. It was the closest to real first-team football I have seen at that age.”

Longwell is on the lookout for his next challenge and will bring with him the font of knowledge he has gained in the US, the UK, and also wider Europe, where he has travelled to leading clubs to tap into their expertise. This has included fact-finding trips to the likes of Real Madrid, Inter Milan, Malaga, and Monaco among many others.

Longwell said: “Football is football, but there are different ways to play it and there are different philosophies and methodologies. Whenever you visit a club, you always want to pick up at least one thing. You might pick up ten but you are always looking for something that makes you do things that bit better if possible.

“Some people are very closed-minded, they never change: but for me, football has evolved a lot and you must be open-minded.

David Longwell explaining tactics
Image: Burnley FC

“One of the biggest differences at the top end of football is how athletic the game is. If you look at the high-speed running, the sprint distance, and the speed the players play at now, it is different from 20 years ago.

“Players at the highest level need to have athleticism, and need to know how to play football. It’s not one or the other – for me, you need both now at the top level. If you look at top, top players like Haaland, Mbappe, Jude Bellingham — even if you look at the Scottish lads, I know John McGinn had to work so hard with his body since he went down south. If you look at him now, he’s in incredible condition. I spoke to him on WhatsApp when he went to Aston Villa, and he said he had to do so much more gym work to improve his body to compete.

“You must improve all those aspects of it. So when I go into a football club, I’m always looking for that small thing I can take back, and that was always my mindset going in somewhere. Some clubs would reinforce what you were doing within your academy, or some clubs would make you think you should adapt what you do.

“I’ve been so lucky. I’ve been to so many football clubs and learned so many things, each time taking that little bit and then implementing it into my own style. I’ve been lucky to recently work with Vincent Kompany at Burnley and Jesse Marsch when I was at Red Bulls — two modern, high-level elite coaches.

“Football is always evolving. One of the biggest things I learned at Red Bull was how you profile talent, how you identify talent, and how you coach talent. Look at how many world-class players have come from the Red Bull system. When I go into all these other clubs, I’m always interested to know how they identify talent and how they hone that talent to take it to the highest level.

“At every club I have worked at, alignment through the academy to the first team is key. I feel I have developed that to ensure players do progress to the first team which, at the end of the day, is the main purpose of any academy.”

Keep up to date with the latest news
from Football Careers

including recent placements, in-depth interviews with our clients, career advice segments, guest columns, and more. Our members can access exclusive content centred around working in the world of football, created by the people who know it best.

    I can’t thank Football Careers enough for the professional CV they created for me. The attention to detail is outstanding and the design is eye-catching. I really appreciate all of the support and guidance their team has given me over the years.

    Robbie Fowler, Coach & Former Professional Footballer

    Football Careers knew every detail about the role I was interested in and gave me comprehensive advice on how to prepare for a successful interview. The team was attentive and took time to answer all my questions. The knowledge they’ve shared with me has helped me secure a new role and it will be invaluable in my future career.

    Selmen Sassi, Coach & Former Professional Footballer

    I would like to thank Football Careers for their professional preparation of my CV and PowerPoint presentation. Without their input, I wouldn’t have found the recent job opportunities that have come my way. I would highly recommend Football Careers to anyone involved in football.

    Frank Sinclair, Coach & Former Professional Footballer

    I’ve had my CV and LinkedIn profile done by Football Careers. They’ve helped me out, they’ve offered me advice and guidance, and the staff couldn’t be more helpful. I would recommend them to any coach.

    Diarmuid O'Carroll, Assistant Manager & Former Professional Footballer

    Football Careers does fantastic work. So happy to be a part of such a professional agency and thankful for their help!

    Éamon Zayed, Head Coach & Former Professional Footballer

    Football Careers worked tirelessly to create a top-quality CV and philosophy documents that perfectly capture my ideas on how to run a football club. They have been a joy to work with from the very beginning and their outstanding final products have already proven to be a very useful career tool.

    Derek Adams, First Team Manager

    Football Careers has helped me greatly with my football CV and my management brochure. They’re very professional and the design of the documents is fantastic. I’ve had the pleasure of working with them for a couple of years now and I would highly recommend them.

    Pa-Modou Kah, Head Coach & Former Professional Footballer

    Football Careers were a huge support to me in my transition from playing to coaching. A first-class service to those who are looking to give themselves the best opportunity for face-to-face interviews.

    Paddy McCourt, Assistant Manager

    Top service once again from Football Careers, thanks for all of your help with updating my CV.

    Clint Hill, Assistant Manager & Former Professional Footballer

    Thanks to Football Careers for their help over the years. I highly recommend their services!

    Stevie Grieve, First Team Manager

    A big thank you to Football Careers for the yearly update of my CV. If you’re looking for a CV, get in touch. Best in the business!

    Ross Ballantyne, Head of Academy Goalkeeping

    Since utilising my CV, I have had interviews at a number of English Premier League and SPFL clubs before accepting a role in the USA. It is definitely a service which I will continue to use.

    Graeme Henderson

    The team members at Football Careers are very approachable and they have excellent knowledge of the football industry. I received a highly professional service from them and I now have a detailed, eye-catching CV that any employer would be attracted to.

    Kevin Nicholson, Club Services Manager

    Football Careers helped me successfully apply for my first full-time coaching job. They provide a fantastic, professional service with a great final product. The team is a pleasure to deal with and I couldn’t be happier with the service provided.

    Luke Chadwick, Head Coach & Franchise Owner

    Working with Football Careers has opened up new opportunities for me. I am delighted with the quality of their service and the results that I received. The work produced by the team has been consistently excellent and I strongly recommend their services to any ambitious coaches.

    Jose Gomez

    Football Careers’ membership features have been a great help to me over the years. The job board is fantastic. It’s quick and easy to use, and there is a wide range of jobs available that are based all over the world. Being an Elite Hosted member gives me unlimited access to the job board, so I can apply for as many roles as I like.

    Jordan Tait, Lead PDP Coach

    I would highly recommend Football Careers. Following a consultation, I was provided with a new professional CV and LinkedIn profile as well as very useful interview coaching. Given the highly competitive football job market, the support they offer is invaluable.

    Barry Horgan, Research Manager & Sports Scientist

    I highly recommend becoming a member of Football Careers. You’ll receive the benefits and opportunities you seek in football. The services offer good value for money and above all, give you the access and tools you need to apply for high-level positions globally.

    Niall Connolly, Director of Coaching

    Fantastic service and professionalism of the highest order! Top-class staff who go the extra mile with a personal and professional approach. I highly recommend Football Careers, thank you always!

    Dave Rogers, YDP Lead Coach

    Thanks to Football Careers for the brilliant CV and cover letter to help with my future. First-class service and an unbelievable, new-look CV! I thoroughly recommend them, thanks again.

    Ross Stormonth, Assistant Manager

    Thank you to Football Careers for your quality products and outstanding service. I highly recommend them to any football professionals.

    Paul Gray, Academy Manager

    I would highly recommend Football Careers to anyone looking to obtain a CV of outstanding quality and attention to detail. I have just received mine and it’s first-class.

    Darren Murphy, First Team Manager

    A massive thank you to Football Careers for redesigning and updating my CV. If you’re looking to give your career prospects a boost, I would highly recommend getting in touch with them.

    Brian McDermott, YDP Coach

    Become A Member

    Create an account and access a limited number of the latest sports vacancies. Apply for up to five directly from your profile.

    Or, become a full member and gain additional benefits including access to all listings on the Job Board, your own candidate page and access to all news articles and expert career advice for a small monthly fee.