David Longwell on Player Development in the US and Scotland
- Longwell has gained a unique perspective on player development, having been an Academy Director in Scotland, England, and North America
- He says: "It’s not about anyone winning leagues or cups — that’s a bonus. What you must do is accelerate the players and challenge them quicker."
David Longwell says the return of Under-20s football could help build a better pathway to the top for young players in Scotland.
National team boss Steve Clarke has already warned that the country needs to change its approach to developing young talent. And a Scottish FA report earlier this year said that clubs are failing to bring through enough young players, adding that Scottish football is “significantly underachieving its potential” in youth development compared to other countries of a similar size.
Longwell has worked as an academy director in Scotland and England, as well as in North America’s MLS with Orlando City and New York Red Bulls. As academy manager at St Mirren, he helped bring through John McGinn, Kenny McLean, and Lewis Morgan – all now key members of Clarke’s Scotland squad. Longwell said:
“When Mark Wotte was in charge at the SFA he introduced the Under-20s league, and in that league, you could play three over-age players. This turned out to be a very good idea. Every club had to play on a Monday or Tuesday evening, and it had to be in a stadium. It was beneficial in bringing young players through.
“I genuinely thought what was in place then worked. It allowed clubs to play young players like we did to accelerate their development but when required, it also allowed first-team players to gain minutes. It was up to each club how they used the Under-20s league but as we used it as a vehicle for development, there were so many young players who progressed to our first team.
“I sat in a meeting and they talked about going back to the reserve league — I thought that was crazy because the Under-20s league was working. However, at that time it was being driven by people who weren’t on the ground. I can only judge it on myself and the club I was at, but we used that league to play young players.




